Mission
home

Common Mistakes & Other Points for Discussion

Tags
Outline
Essential to have before writing, especially in an exam situation
The point is to put on paper ideas that have already been prepared, NOT to figure out what to say during the writing
Strong thesis and clear plan regarding examples and body paragraphs
No right answer, but texts often have certain aspects you are expected to discuss
Important examples → the first body paragraph or at the beginning of a body paragraph
Develop a method of organization that works for you individually → no need to be neat
Does NOT need to cover the conclusion
Spend roughly 5~10 minutes to plan
Introduction
First sentence
Recommended but not necessary to have a hook or some interesting comment → state the text and topic
Background information
Reduce the text or topic to its constituent pieces of information and summarize them → should not be writing a summary in the body
Avoid being vague or ambiguous with word choice
There is a serious problem (X) → what is the problem?
The characters are having a discussion (X) → what is the discussion about?
Thesis
Must be
the final sentence of the introduction
a single sentence
Be consistent with keywords (e.g. prompt, topic, theme, literary term) → should never be replaced by synonyms
Recommended sentence structure: first the argument, then the topics of body paragraphs
→ This text [purpose/argument] … A, B, and C.
Does NOT always have to include topics of body paragraphs, especially if the sentence becomes too long
Body
Topic sentence
No need to be particularly creative or insightful → largely repeats parts of the thesis
Analysis
Typically, each step = one sentence → one example = three sentences
A particular step may need two sentences, but a single example → no more than five sentences
Avoid combining two steps into one sentence
Be concise, but choose examples so that each one can be analyzed in 3-4 sentences
Non-literary text: freely refer to the author and audience
However, AVOID writing from the perspective of the audience
The audience realizes… (X) / The passage conveys… (O)
Writing about a short passage: you are by default doing close reading
→ as many examples as possible, as specific as possible
Step 1
Pinpoint a clear moment in the text → your reader should not have to re-read the text
Do NOT include a literary term in this step → leave literary term for step 2
Using a quote:
Do NOT simply lift a phrase out of the text and drop it into your essay
The passage uses the quote “a river flooding through a narrow canyon.” (X)
In fact, you should never need to use the word “quote”
Fit the quote into your sentence in a grammatically correct manner
The passage describes the way the heart creates sound as “a river flooding through a narrow canyon.” (O)
Check grammar by considering the sentence with quotation marks removed
Choose a short enough phrase so that the quote can fit into your sentence
Avoid quoting an entire sentence from the text
Do NOT write a sentence that is entirely a quote
Choose an interesting use of language—in other words, a stylistic choice—rather than writing blandly
Paraphrase important information while quoting stylistic choices
Step 2
Explain something that the text does not literally state, even if that something seems obvious or intuitive
Avoid reusing words from the quote in step 1
Do NOT directly refer to the argument in the thesis → leave this part for step 3
Significance of an example includes:
Characteristic or quality of whatever is being described
e.g. Describing a person as a turtle → that person is slow
Important idea or motif in the text
Character’s emotion
Attitude or perspective of a character or the author
Atmosphere or tone of the text
Hint regarding a future event in the plot
Connotation of a particular word
Step 3
Reiterate the argument in the thesis → use same keywords for theme or topic
Can feel repetitive, but ideally every example should connect to thesis in a slightly different way
However, if the example is very straightforward, steps 2 and 3 may be combined
Should not happen often
If the passage itself is very straightforward, consider writing four examples in a body paragraph
Do NOT describe what happens next in the plot
Conclusion
Restating the thesis
Does not need to be long, since this part simply repeats what has already been stated (also the reason that the conclusion needs to do something more)
Broader ideas
Discuss an idea or point that has not appeared before
Show that you are pondering a larger significance → you do NOT need to provide a definitive answer
Force yourself to write 3-4 sentences here
Does not directly contribute to your analysis, but will leave a stronger impression upon your reader
If you are running out of time, remember that analysis is done in introduction and body
→ do NOT rush through just to reach the end of the essay
Simply finish by restating the thesis, but try to write 3-4 sentences for the conclusion